Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner Review

We may earn a commission from some links on this page.

The Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner is a sharpenable pencil with a gel formula: a soft, creamy liner that goes on like a pencil but blends out like a gel. The listing reviewed here is the Fig Shimmer shade, a muted fig tone with shimmer running through it. This review covers what the pencil format is good for, what the brand says about wear, how the shade range is put together, and the steps that keep a liner in place when your lids are oily.

Key Takeaways

  • A sharpenable gel eyeliner pencil, not a liquid liner or a pot of gel with a brush.
  • Sold as longwear, with a formula the brand describes as water-resistant.
  • The range runs from matte to shimmer finishes; the listing here is Fig Shimmer.
  • A pencil gives you control at the lash line and an edge you can soften before it sets.
  • On very oily lids, a primer under the liner does more for staying power than a second coat.

A Gel Formula in a Pencil Body

Most gel liners come in a small pot with a separate brush. This one puts the same kind of soft, pigment-heavy texture inside a pencil you sharpen, which changes how you handle it. There is no brush to load, no pot to keep clean and nothing to dry out, and the point is right there when you open it.

That format suits the lash line. A pencil is easier to place close to the lashes than a brush, especially if you are lining the outer half of the eye or working in a hurry, and it is easy to carry for a touch-up. You can also smudge the line with a small brush or a fingertip in the few seconds before it sets, which is harder to do with a liquid liner that grabs the skin straight away.

The trade-off is the point itself. A pencil line is only as sharp as the tip, so a dull pencil gives a soft, wide line rather than a fine one. Sharpening is part of using it, not an optional extra, and a fresh point is what makes the difference between a smudged smoky line and a defined one.

What the Brand Says About Wear

The product name itself makes the claim: When Pencil Met Gel, with longwear in the listing title. Julep describes the formula as water-resistant and built to resist smudging, sweat and tears. Those are the brand's words, and they are the right thing to judge the pencil against rather than any promise of a fixed number of hours.

Water-resistant and waterproof are not the same claim, and the difference matters at the end of the day. A water-resistant liner copes with sweat, humidity and the odd tear but will usually come away with a standard eye makeup remover or a micellar water. A fully waterproof liner often needs an oil-based remover and a little more patience. If a liner resists everything you try, add an oil-based cleanser rather than rubbing at the eye.

Wear also depends on the lid, not just the pencil. Two people using the same liner can get very different results, because oil production, the shape of the eyelid and how much you touch your eyes all affect how a line holds. A pencil that stays put on a dry lid can still travel on a very oily one, which is why the prep steps below are worth the minute they take.

The Shade Range and Fig Shimmer

Julep offers this pencil in matte and shimmer finishes, from soft neutrals through to stronger colours. Matte shades are the ones to reach for when you want a clean, graphic line or a tightline along the lashes, because there is no particle in them to catch the light.

Fig Shimmer sits at the softer end of the range. Fig reads as a muted purple-brown, and the shimmer lifts it slightly so the line looks less hard than a black pencil. That makes it a good choice for a daytime eye, for a softer version of a smoky look, or for anyone who finds a stark black line too much for everyday wear.

The one thing to know about shimmer shades is that the particles can make a line look less crisp and can move more readily on an oily lid. If you want the definition to hold, keep the shimmer shade to the upper lash line and use a matte pencil on the lower lash line and waterline, where a shimmer tends to travel first.

Sharpening and Application

Because this is a sharpenable pencil, you need a sharpener with a blade wide enough for the barrel. Clean the blade before you use it, sharpen in short turns rather than one long twist, and wipe the tip afterwards, since gel formulas are soft enough to leave residue on the blade.

How you sharpen sets the look. A freshly sharpened point draws a fine line close to the lashes and is the right choice for a defined everyday eye. A tip that has been used a couple of times and blunted slightly gives a softer, wider stroke, which is what you want for a smudged line across the lid.

For application, work in short strokes from the inner corner outwards and keep the elbow of your hand supported so the line stays steady. Build the line in thin layers rather than pressing hard once: gel formulas lay down colour quickly, and a thin layer sets better than a thick one. If you want to smudge it, do that straight away with a small brush, because once the formula sets it stops moving.

Making It Last on Oily Lids

If liner tends to slide on you, the lid is usually the reason rather than the pencil. Start with a clean, dry lid and skip heavy eye cream in the morning, since anything that has not absorbed gives the liner something to travel on. A translucent eye primer, patted thin from the lashes to the crease and given a moment to set, gives the pencil a base that holds far better than bare skin.

Setting the line helps as well. A little matching eyeshadow pressed over the liner with a small brush locks the colour in place, and it also softens a line that has come out too sharp. Keep the outer corner in mind: that is where oil gathers and where a line usually breaks down first, so a thinner line there lasts longer than a heavy one.

For touch-ups during the day, blot the lid with a tissue first and then redraw rather than layering new liner over old. A cotton bud with a little micellar water cleans up any travel under the eye without disturbing the rest of the makeup.

Detailed Features

These are the details that decide whether the pencil suits you, taken from the listing and the brand's description of the product.

FeatureWhat it means
FormatA sharpenable gel pencil, so the line is only as fine as the point you sharpen.
FinishShimmer in this Fig Shimmer listing, with matte and shimmer shades across the range.
Wear claimSold as longwear, and the brand describes the formula as water-resistant.
ApplicationGlides on as a pencil and can be smudged before it sets.
RemovalComes away with a standard eye makeup remover or micellar water.
Best forA defined lash line, a soft smoky edge, or a softer colour than black.

The practical point is the point itself. A pencil that sharpens well and holds a tip is easy to work with; one that crumbles at the sharpener is not, whatever the formula claims. Keep the sharpener clean and the pencil will draw the same line from the first use to the last.

Advantages and Disadvantages

The advantage of this format is control. A pencil is easier to place than a liquid liner, it can be softened before it sets, and there is no brush or pot to look after. The water-resistant finish and the longwear claim are what make it useful for a full day rather than a short evening, and the Fig Shimmer shade gives you a softer alternative to black.

  • Advantages: easy placement at the lash line, blendable before it sets, no brush or pot, water-resistant formula, and a shade that works for daytime.
  • Disadvantages: needs sharpening to stay precise, shimmer shades can travel on oily lids, and the wear claim depends heavily on how oily your lids are.

That balance makes it a sensible everyday pencil rather than a specialist one. If you want a hard, graphic line that survives a full shift, a matte shade with a primer underneath is the way to use it. If you want something soft that you can smudge and forget about, the shimmer shade does that job without much effort.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is It Waterproof?

Julep describes the formula as water-resistant, which is a step below waterproof. It should cope with sweat, humidity and tears, but a standard eye makeup remover or micellar water will normally take it off. If it holds on more than you expect, use an oil-based cleanser and let it sit for a moment before wiping.

Can You Use It on the Waterline?

The pencil format makes it possible to work along the waterline, and a matte shade is the better choice there because shimmer tends to travel. Keep the tip out of the eye itself, sharpen it first so you are not dragging a used point across a sensitive area, and stop if your eyes sting or water.

How Do You Sharpen a Gel Pencil?

Use a sharpener with a blade wide enough for the barrel, clean the blade first, and turn the pencil in short twists rather than one long one. Gel formulas are soft, so they leave residue on the blade and can crumble if you press too hard. Wipe the tip and the blade after each sharpen.

Does a Shimmer Shade Smudge More?

Shimmer particles can make a line look less crisp and can travel more readily on an oily lid, so a shimmer shade is the one most likely to move by the end of the day. A primer underneath and a matte pencil on the lower lash line are the simplest ways to keep it in place.

How Do You Take It Off?

Soak a cotton pad with eye makeup remover or micellar water, hold it against the closed eye for a few seconds so the formula softens, then wipe gently downwards. There is no need to rub, and rubbing is what irritates the eye area most. Follow with your usual cleanser.

Concluding Thoughts

The Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner is a straightforward pencil to live with: it draws easily at the lash line, it can be softened before it sets, and the Fig Shimmer shade gives you a softer alternative to black for daytime. The longwear and water-resistant claims are the brand's, and they hold up best when the lid is prepped rather than bare.

If your lids are oily, treat the primer as part of the routine rather than an optional extra, and set the line with a little shadow. If they are not, the pencil is about as simple as eyeliner gets: sharpen it, draw, smudge if you want to, and take it off with a normal remover at the end of the day. On that basis it is a reliable everyday liner rather than a specialist one, and the shade range gives you room to go softer or sharper depending on the look.